EXAMINING THE UTILITY OF MODELS IN EVALUATING ANTICANCER THERAPIES: FROM LAB TO CLINIC

Main Article Content

Garla Venkateswarlu1, Sachin Kumar2, Ramesh Bodla1*

Keywords

anticancer, preclinical models, animal models, tumor heterogeneity.

Abstract

Evaluating anticancer therapies necessitates a comprehensive understanding of their efficacy and safety profiles before clinical translation. Models are pivotal in bridging the gap between laboratory research and clinical applications by providing valuable insights into treatment outcomes. This review explores the utility of different models in assessing anticancer therapies and their potential to guide clinical decision-making. Preclinical models, including cell lines and animal models, offer controlled environments for initial evaluations but face challenges in replicating the complex dynamics of human tumors. Patient-derived models, such as organoids and xenografts, offer personalized assessments of therapy response and enable the investigation of tumor heterogeneity. However, challenges related to scalability, standardization, and ethical considerations exist. This review discusses the strengths and limitations of these model types, their complementary roles, and the importance of their integration in comprehensive therapy evaluation. Furthermore, future perspectives and challenges are highlighted, including enhanced model integration, incorporation of real-world heterogeneity, improved predictive power and personalization, validation and standardization efforts, and ethical and regulatory considerations. By addressing these challenges, model-based evaluations can enhance the translation of promising anticancer therapies from the laboratory to the clinic, ultimately benefiting cancer patients.

Downloads

References


1. Chanchal DK, Pradesh U. Various medicinal plants used in the treatment of anticancer activity. Int. J. Pharm. Sci. Res. 2018 Apr 1;9(4):1424-9. doi: 10.13040/IJPSR.0975-8232. 2. https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/understanding/statistics. [Cite dated 18-05-2022]. 3. Iqbal J, Abbasi BA, Mahmood T, Kanwal S, Ali B, Shah SA, Khalil AT. Plant-derived anticancer agents: A green anticancer approach. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Biomedicine. 2017 Dec 1;7(12):1129-50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apjtb.2017.10.016 4. Krishnamurthi K. Screening of natural products for anticancer and antidiabetic properties. Health administrator. 2000;20(1&2):69. 5. Ruggeri BA, Camp F and Miknyoczki S: Animal Models of Disease: Preclinical Animal Models of Cancer and Their Applications and Utility in Drug Discovery. Biochemical Pharmacology 2014; 87(1): 150-61. doi: 10.1016/j.bcp.2013.06.020. Epub 2013 Jun 28. 6. C. Singh, S. Khan, F. Bamne and I. Ansari, Preclinical Experimental Screening Models for the Assessment of Anticancer drugs, International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research, 2021; 12(4): 1966-1977. 7. Van Dyke T and Jacks T: Cancer Modeling in the Modern Era. Cell 2002; 108(2): 135-44. 8. Morgan KM, Riedlinger GM, Rosenfeld J, Ganesan S, Pine SR. Patient-Derived Xenograft Models of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer and Their Potential Utility in Personalized Medicine. Front Oncol. 2017 Jan 19;7:2. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2017.00002. PMID: 28154808; PMCID: PMC5243815. 9. Singh M and Johnson L: Using Genetically Engineered Mouse Models of Cancer to Aid Drug Development: An Industry Perspective. Clinical Cancer Research 2006; 12(18): 5312-28. 10. Teicher BA: Tumor Models for Efficacy Determination. Molecular Cancer Therapeutics 2006; 5(10): 2435–-43. 11. Sausville EA and Burger AM: Contributions of Human Tumor Xenografts to Anticancer Drug Development. Cancer Research 2006; 66(7): 3351-4. 12. Kaitin KI and Di-Masi JA: Pharmaceutical Innovation in the 21st Century: New Drug Approvals in the First Decade, 2000-2009. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 2010; 89(2): 183-8. 13. Ledford H: Translational Research: 4 Ways to Fix the Clinical Trial. Nature 2011; 477(7366): 526-8. 14. Pitter KL, Galbán CJ, Galbán S, Saeed-Tehrani O, Li F, Charles N, Bradbury MS, Becher OJ, Chenevert TL, Rehemtulla A: Perifosine and CCI 779 Co-Operate to Induce Cell Death and Decrease Proliferation in PTEN-Intact and PTEN-Deficient PDGF-Driven Murine Glioblastoma. PLoS ONE 2011; 6(1): 14545. 15. Chen Z, Cheng K, Walton Z, Wang Y, Ebi H, Shimamura T, Liu Y, Tupper T, Ouyang J and Li J: A Murine Lung Cancer Co-Clinical Trial Identifies Genetic Modifiers of Therapeutic Response. Nature 2012: 483(7391): 613-17. 16. Chanda S, Nagani K. In vitro and in vivo methods for anticancer activity evaluation and some Indian medicinal plants possessing anticancer properties: an overview. Journal of pharmacognosy and phytochemistry. 2013 Jul 1;2(2). 17. Unnikrishnan MC, Ramadasan K. Cytotoxicity of extracts of spices to cultured cells. Nutr Cancer 1998; 11: 251-257. 18. Goodspeed A, Heiser LM, Gray JW, Costello JC. Tumor-Derived Cell Lines as Molecular Models of Cancer Pharmacogenomics. Mol Cancer Res. 2016 Jan;14(1):3-13. 19. Amaral MVS, DE Sousa Portilho AJ, DA Silva EL, DE Oliveira Sales L, DA Silva Maués JH, DE Moraes MEA, Moreira-Nunes CA. Establishment of Drug-resistant Cell Lines as a Model in Experimental Oncology: A Review. Anticancer Res. 2019 Dec;39(12):6443-6455. 20. Strober W. Trypan blue exclusion test of cell viability. Curr Protoc Immunol. 2001 May; Appendix 3: Appendix 3B. 21. Avelar-Freitas BA, Almeida VG, Pinto MC, Mourão FA, Massensini AR, Martins-Filho OA, Rocha-Vieira E, Brito-Melo GE. Trypan blue exclusion assay by flow cytometry. Braz J Med Biol Res. 2014 Apr;47(4):307-15. 22. Miao P, Sheng S, Sun X, Liu J, Huang G. Lactate dehydrogenase A in cancer: a promising target for diagnosis and therapy. IUBMB Life. 2013 Nov;65(11):904-10. 23. Kumar S, Bajaj S, Bodla RB. Preclinical screening methods in cancer. Indian J Pharmacol. 2016 Sep-Oct;48(5):481-486. 24. Kumar P, Nagarajan A, Uchil PD. Analysis of Cell Viability by the MTT Assay. Cold Spring Harb Protoc. 2018 Jun 1;2018(6). doi: 10.1101/pdb.prot095505. 25. Loures FV, Levitz SM. XTT Assay of Antifungal Activity. Bio Protoc. 2015 Aug 5;5(15):e1543. doi: 10.21769/bioprotoc.1543. 26. Voigt W. Sulforhodamine B assay and chemosensitivity. Humana Press; 2005. 27. Vichai V, Kirtikara K. Sulforhodamine B colorimetric assay for cytotoxicity screening. Nature protocols. 2006 Aug;1(3):1112-6. 28. Errington TM, Iorns E, Gunn W, Tan FE, Lomax J, Nosek BA. An open investigation of the reproducibility of cancer biology research. Elife. 2014 Dec 10;3:e04333. doi: 10.7554/eLife.04333. 29. Brix N, Samaga D, Belka C, Zitzelsberger H, Lauber K. Analysis of clonogenic growth in vitro. Nat Protoc. 2021 Nov;16(11):4963-4991. doi: 10.1038/s41596-021-00615-0. 30. Kim JB. Three-dimensional tissue culture models in cancer biology. In Seminars in cancer biology 2005 Oct 1 (Vol. 15, No. 5, pp. 365-377). Academic Press. 31. Van Zundert I, Fortuni B, Rocha S. From 2D to 3D cancer cell models—The enigmas of drug delivery research. Nanomaterials. 2020 Nov 11;10(11):2236. 32. Colombo E, Cattaneo MG. Multicellular 3D models to study Tumour-Stroma interactions. International journal of molecular sciences. 2021 Feb 5;22(4):1633. 33. Chaicharoenaudomrung N, Kunhorm P, Noisa P. Three-dimensional cell culture systems as an in vitro platform for cancer and stem cell modeling. World journal of stem cells. 2019 Dec 12;11(12):1065. 34. Wang C, Tang Z, Zhao Y, Yao R, Li L, Sun W. Three-dimensional in vitro cancer models: a short review. Biofabrication. 2014 Apr 14;6(2):022001. 35. Rodrigues T, Kundu B, Silva-Correia J, Kundu SC, Oliveira JM, Reis RL, Correlo VM. Emerging tumor spheroids technologies for 3D in vitro cancer modeling. Pharmacology & therapeutics. 2018 Apr 1;184:201-11. 36. Li W, Khan M, Mao S, Feng S, Lin JM. Advances in tumor-endothelial cells co-culture and interaction on microfluidics. Journal of pharmaceutical analysis. 2018 Aug 1;8(4):210-8. 37. Baghban R, Roshangar L, Jahanban-Esfahlan R, Seidi K, Ebrahimi-Kalan A, Jaymand M, Kolahian S, Javaheri T, Zare P. Tumor microenvironment complexity and therapeutic implications at a glance. Cell Communication and Signaling. 2020 Dec;18:1-9. 38. Tan ML, Ling L, Fischbach C. Engineering strategies to capture the biological and biophysical tumor microenvironment in vitro. Advanced drug delivery reviews. 2021 Sep 1;176:113852. 39. Yuki K, Cheng N, Nakano M, Kuo CJ. Organoid models of tumor immunology. Trends in immunology. 2020 Aug 1;41(8):652-64. 40. Porter RJ, Murray GI, McLean MH. Current concepts in tumour-derived organoids. British journal of cancer. 2020 Oct 13;123(8):1209-18. 41. Rodrigues J, Heinrich MA, Teixeira LM, Prakash J. 3D in vitro model (R) evolution: unveiling tumor–stroma interactions. Trends in cancer. 2021 Mar 1;7(3):249-64. 42. Rossi G, Manfrin A, Lutolf MP. Progress and potential in organoid research. Nature Reviews Genetics. 2018 Nov;19(11):671-87. 43. Schuster B, Junkin M, Kashaf SS, Romero-Calvo I, Kirby K, Matthews J, Weber CR, Rzhetsky A, White KP, Tay S. Automated microfluidic platform for dynamic and combinatorial drug screening of tumor organoids. Nature communications. 2020 Oct 19;11(1):5271. 44. Fatehullah A, Tan SH, Barker N. Organoids as an in vitro model of human development and disease. Nature cell biology. 2016 Mar;18(3):246-54. 45. Atat OE, Farzaneh Z, Pourhamzeh M, Taki F, Abi-Habib R, Vosough M, El-Sibai M. 3D modeling in cancer studies. Human Cell. 2022:1-4. 46. Pasch CA, Favreau PF, Yueh AE, Babiarz CP, Gillette AA, Sharick JT, Karim MR, Nickel KP, DeZeeuw AK, Sprackling CM, Emmerich PB. Patient-derived cancer organoid cultures to predict sensitivity to chemotherapy and radiation. Clinical Cancer Research. 2019 Sep 1;25(17):5376-87. 47. Qu J, Kalyani FS, Liu L, Cheng T, Chen L. Tumor organoids: Synergistic applications, current challenges, and future prospects in cancer therapy. Cancer Communications. 2021 Dec;41(12):1331-53. 48. Lee SH, Hu W, Matulay JT, Silva MV, Owczarek TB, Kim K, Chua CW, Barlow LJ, Kandoth C, Williams AB, Bergren SK. Tumor evolution and drug response in patient-derived organoid models of bladder cancer. Cell. 2018 Apr 5;173(2):515-28. 49. Sailer V, von Amsberg G, Duensing S, Kirfel J, Lieb V, Metzger E, Offermann A, Pantel K, Schuele R, Taubert H, Wach S. Experimental in vitro, ex vivo and in vivo models in prostate cancer research. Nature Reviews Urology. 2023 Mar;20(3):158-78. 50. https://www.cellink.com/blog/what-are-spheroids-and-why-are-they-important/ 51. Kim DH, Beebe DJ, Levchenko A. Micro-and nanoengineering for stem cell biology: the promise with a caution. Trends in biotechnology. 2011 Aug 1;29(8):399-408. 52. Mu X, Zheng W, Sun J, Zhang W, Jiang X. Microfluidics for manipulating cells. small. 2013 Jan 14;9(1):9-21. 53. Luo T, Fan L, Zhu R, Sun D. Microfluidic single-cell manipulation and analysis: Methods and applications. Micromachines. 2019 Feb 1;10(2):104. 54. Ho CM, Ng SH, Li KH, Yoon YJ. 3D printed microfluidics for biological applications. Lab on a Chip. 2015;15(18):3627-37. 55. Vunjak-Novakovic G, Scadden DT. Biomimetic platforms for human stem cell research. Cell stem cell. 2011 Mar 4;8(3):252-61. 56. Ruggeri BA, Camp F, Miknyoczki S. Animal models of disease: preclinical animal models of cancer and their applications and utility in drug discovery. Biochemical pharmacology. 2014 Jan 1;87(1):150-61. 57. Portillo-Lara R, Annabi N. Microengineered cancer-on-a-chip platforms to study the metastatic microenvironment. Lab on a chip. 2016;16(21):4063-81. 58. Rizzo G, Bertotti A, Leto SM, Vetrano S. Patient-derived tumor models: A more suitable tool for preclinical studies in colorectal cancer. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research. 2021 Jun 1;40(1):178. 59. Drost J, Clevers H. Organoids in cancer research. Nature Reviews Cancer. 2018 Jul;18(7):407-18. 60. Looi CK, Chung FF, Leong CO, Wong SF, Rosli R, Mai CW. Therapeutic challenges and current immunomodulatory strategies in targeting the immunosuppressive pancreatic tumor microenvironment. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research. 2019 Dec;38:1-23. 61. Ruggiero RA, Bustuoabad OD. The biological sense of cancer: a hypothesis. Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling. 2006 Dec;3:1-4. 62. Jadus M, Driggers L, Hoa N, Pham JT, Natividad J, Delgado C, Jeffes EW, Giedzinski E, Limoli C, Ge L. Mechanisms of immune evasion exhibited by different rat glioma cell lines. Neuro-Oncology and Cancer Targeted Therapy. New York, USA, Nova Science Publishers. 2010:109-39. 63. Shah SD, Nayak AP, Sharma P, Villalba DR, Addya S, Huang W, Shapiro P, Kane MA, Deshpande DA. Targeted Inhibition of Select Extracellular Signal-regulated Kinases 1 and 2 Functions Mitigates Pathological Features of Asthma in Mice. American Journal of Respiratory Cell and Molecular Biology. 2023 Jan;68(1):23-38. 64. Katiyar S, Mukhtar HA. Tea in chemoprevention of cancer. International journal of oncology. 1996 Feb 1;8(2):221-38. 65. Li Q, Dong H, Yang G, Song Y, Mou Y, Ni Y. Mouse tumor-bearing models as preclinical study platforms for oral squamous cell carcinoma. Frontiers in oncology. 2020 Feb 25; 10:212. 66. Lippman SM, Hawk ET. Cancer prevention: from 1727 to milestones of the past 100 years. Cancer research. 2009 Jul 1;69(13):5269-84. 67. Rivina L, Davoren MJ, Schiestl RH. Mouse models for radiation-induced cancers. Mutagenesis. 2016 Sep 1;31(5):491-509. 68. McCreery MQ, Balmain A. Chemical carcinogenesis models of cancer: back to the future. Annual Review of Cancer Biology. 2017 Mar 6;1:295-312. 69. Heyer J, Kwong LN, Lowe SW, Chin L. Non-germline genetically engineered mouse models for translational cancer research. Nature Reviews Cancer. 2010 Jul;10(7):470-80. 70. Bos PD, Nguyen DX, Massagué J. Modeling metastasis in the mouse. Current opinion in pharmacology. 2010 Oct 1;10(5):571-7. 71. Lampreht Tratar U, Horvat S, Cemazar M. Transgenic mouse models in cancer research. Frontiers in oncology. 2018 Jul 20;8:268. 72. Stribbling SM, Ryan AJ. The cell-line-derived subcutaneous tumor model in preclinical cancer research. Nature Protocols. 2022 Sep;17(9):2108-28. 73. Tabassum, D. P., & Polyak, K. (2015). Tumorigenesis: it takes a village. Nature reviews. Cancer, 15(8), 473–483. 74. Toolan HW. Successful Subcutaneous Growth and Transplantation of Human Tumors in X-Irradiated Laboratory Animals. Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine. 1951;77(3):572-578. doi:10.3181/00379727-77-18854 75. Morgan, K. M., Riedlinger, G. M., Rosenfeld, J., Ganesan, S., & Pine, S. R. (2017). Patient-Derived Xenograft Models of Nonsmall Cell Lung Cancer and Their Potential Utility in Personalized Medicine. Frontiers in oncology, 7, 2. 76. Kyriazis, A. A., & Kyriazis, A. P. (1980). Preferential sites of growth of human tumors in nude mice following subcutaneous transplantation. Cancer research, 40(12), 4509–4511. 77. Byrne, A. T., Alférez, D. G., Amant, F., Annibali, D., Arribas, J., Biankin, A. V., Bruna, A., Budinská, E., Caldas, C., Chang, D. K., Clarke, R. B., Clevers, H., Coukos, G., Dangles-Marie, V., Eckhardt, S. G., Gonzalez-Suarez, E., Hermans, E., Hidalgo, M., Jarzabek, M. A., de Jong, S., … Trusolino, L. (2017). Interrogating open issues in cancer precision medicine with patient-derived xenografts. Nature reviews. Cancer, 17(4), 254–268. 78. Kemper, K., Krijgsman, O., Cornelissen-Steijger, P., Shahrabi, A., Weeber, F., Song, J. Y., Kuilman, T., Vis, D. J., Wessels, L. F., Voest, E. E., Schumacher, T. N., Blank, C. U., Adams, D. J., Haanen, J. B., & Peeper, D. S. (2015). Intra- and inter-tumor heterogeneity in a vemurafenib-resistant melanoma patient and derived xenografts. EMBO molecular medicine, 7(9), 1104–1118. 79. Bleijs M, van de Wetering M, Clevers H, Drost J. Xenograft and organoid model systems in cancer research. The EMBO journal. 2019 Aug 1;38(15):e101654. 80. Julien S, Merino-Trigo A, Lacroix L, Pocard M, Goéré D, Mariani P, Landron S, Bigot L, Nemati F, Dartigues P, Weiswald LB. Characterization of a large panel of patient-derived tumor xenografts representing the clinical heterogeneity of human colorectal cancer. Clinical Cancer Research. 2012 Oct 1;18(19):5314-28. 81. Mi Q, Pezzuto JM, Farnsworth NR, Wani MC, Kinghorn AD, Swanson SM. Use of the in vivo hollow fiber assay in natural products anticancer drug discovery. J Nat Prod. 2009;72(3):573-580. 82. Chew CH, Lee C-W, Huang W-T, Cheng L-W, Chen A, Cheng T-M, Liu Y-L, Chen C-C. Microtube Array Membrane (MTAM)-Based Encapsulated Cell Therapy for Cancer Treatment. Membranes. 2020; 10(5):80.